|
@ 11:04 am (GMT) |
Scott StruifHornady released this video today, extolling the virtues of the 7mm-08 as an elk cartridge. I dont know why I watch shit like this, because Nathan has taught me to know better. The conversation starts with 3 relatively intelligent grown men discussing their beards. Thats a dead-giveaway. But confirmation bias somehow draws me into suffering through hours of blather about BC, SD, FPS, FPE, etc.https://youtu.be/4YFvDLCrp9E |
|
@ 12:35 pm (GMT) |
VinceRe: 7mm-08 garbageIt could have been worse Scott, at least they werent advocating the 6.5 cm |
|
@ 07:56 am (GMT) |
Scott StruifRe: 7mm-08 garbageTrue, Vince. But why would they piss on their own shoes when they just released an adequate cartridge, the 7mm PRS? Supposed experts in the US seem to think telling people what they want to hear is more important than giving them good advice. If you cant handle recoil, youve no business hunting elk. |
|
@ 11:10 am (GMT) |
Daniel PrattRe: 7mm-08 garbageI'll throw my 2 cents or more accurately just my experience with a like powered cartridge and big game.I feel your sentiment on that particular parts of that podcast and how they frame some of their statements. A bit overly positive... (to put it nicely)? I do understand your reaction to degree. They are marketing people though, that's how they roll. That being said, I haven't hunted many Elk and don't shoot a 7mm-08 much (so obviously I'm no expert on the specific topic). I understand Elk are pretty tough, maybe tougher than moose? They are smaller, but have that reputation. Maybe they also have that reputation a bit because so many more people hunt them and fail? I'm not sure there. Either way, I would likely not use 7mm-08 as an end all, be all, for that hunting purpose. That being said, I do use a custom 7x57 for the majority of my big game hunting now. I own many larger rifles and a have drifted away from them for various reasons. My high volume of recreational shooting being one of them. To the point, I live in Fairbanks, Alaska and hunt moose, caribou, and Dall Sheep every year. Not always successfully, but I've never really had any issues when I do find a "shootable" animal. The 7x57 is similar to the 7mm-08 in ballistics though it has a definite advantage using longer heavier bullets due to having more case capacity. I currently use 180gr. ELDMs at 2592 fps avg. for all the aforementioned animal species. I know, 7mm-08 won't launch 180s that fast without being a bit spicy. So far with that rifle, I have killed five moose at ranges between 30 and 400 yards, over a dozen caribou 50 to 600 yards, and two sheep at 371 and 520 yards. I've also killed a black bear at 10 yards with that rifle, but that probably could have been done with a bow...or a spear... None of those animals ran more than 50 yards (not including one sheep rolling >500 ft off a cliff side). Most of them including the moose went less than 10 yards or were DRT. My point is that for hunting elk or elk sized animals at close ranges (0-200) I don't think a heavy bullet in a 7mm-08 would be a bad choice necessarily. Especially for a recoil sensitive shooter. Would it be my first choice? No, surely not. I also know that people who say you "need" a .338 Win Mag or .375 H&H to hunt moose have obviously not hunted many moose. Anyhow, good observation on the somewhat hyped podcast content, also annoys me a bit. Thanks for the link too, makes it easy to immediately see the exact referred content. Good luck out there, -Daniel |
|
@ 01:04 am (GMT) |
Anders ÖsterbergRe: 7mm-08 garbageHere in Sweden we shoot thousands of Moose with 6.5x55 and with a good hit I'm the lungs they go down pretty quickly.I dot think that a Elk is any tougher to punch a hole in . I f the hitting speed is enough to expand the bullet the animal will die |
|
@ 01:04 am (GMT) |
Anders ÖsterbergRe: 7mm-08 garbageHere in Sweden we shoot thousands of Moose with 6.5x55 and with a good hit I'm the lungs they go down pretty quickly.I dot think that a Elk is any tougher to punch a hole in . I f the hitting speed is enough to expand the bullet the animal will die |
|
@ 07:34 am (GMT) |
Scott StruifRe: 7mm-08 garbageHere in the US, we wound thousands of animals with under-powered cartridges. Wildlife management biologists cant keep track of the number of wounded animals that run off and die.My reaction to the Hornady video about the 7mm-08 was more about why werent they touting their new 7mmPRC? Sure, the 6.5x55 and 7x57 are fine for perfect, broadside, behind the shoulder shots. Nobody can win an argument saying theyre not. But anybody who argues that weaker cartridges are fine because they make recoil-sensitive shooters better shots is admitting he cant take recoil. |
|
@ 08:16 am (GMT) |
Luis VazquezRe: 7mm-08 garbageGood afternoon Gents:I've seen many elk taken down with a 7mm-08, 280 Rem, 7RSAUM, 7mm Rem mag, and 270 Win. This is pretty much all our family has used in the last 35 years. Pretty much a 7mm family, and I wouldn't say a 7mm is not enough for elk. The only difference between these cartridges, is the reach. Shot placement and bullet selection is key, regardless of cartridge. Last fall 2 hunters lost 2 wounded deer, both shot with 300 Win Mags, more than enough cartridge for a small coues deer, but why were they lost? poor shot placement. I've used the 7mm-08 off and on for over 35 year now, and the one deer I lost about 20 years ago, was because it was a rushed gut shot, and it still turns my stomach every time I think of it. I tracked it for a day and a half, and couldn't find it. Now why Hornady praises the 7mm-08 instead of the 7mm PRC? no clue. But I wouldn't say the 7mm-08 is garbage. It was designed as a Silhouette Competition cartridge yes, but it is also a very effective hunting cartridge, when used correctly an within it's limitations It is not a long range cartridge, but up to 500 or 600 yards depending on the load, it works great. The factory ammo is mostly junk, but for a reloader, it is a great cartridge. A far as Hornady podcasts, I don't waste my time with them. Regards Luis |
|
@ 11:07 pm (GMT) |
Simon CrowtherRe: 7mm-08 garbageI can't bear to listen to these videos anymore. I went on a club hunt recently and had to sit around the campfire listening to people extolling the virtues of the 6.5 Creedmore, I can't stand it.I've had a 7mm-08 for years and it's OK but overall nothing special. I'm sure here in NZ there are people that have taken Wapiti with a 223 but that doesn't make it an ideal cartridge for the job and neither is the 7mm-08. I've read Nathan's review on the 7mm-08 and I'd say it's spot on. I regard the 7mm-08 as a 300 yard rifle, I know that people take animals much further out with this caliber and the 308 too but I'd prefer not to. I've got a 300 Win Mag for backup, I don't use it much but it's there if I need it. |
|
@ 12:42 pm (GMT) |
Daniel SchindlerRe: 7mm-08 garbageIn my industry, I take a lot of heat for speaking up. So be it. Facts, however, are just that..facts. In this case, I agree that the the cartridge in question has merits...PROVIDED it's limitations are respected. Even the Needmoor can do some things well...with the same provision.IMHO, it always, or should always, come back to ethics. What we owe the game we are hunting. A quick, humane kill. Not optional. For that reason, I personally believe in what I call "cartridge insurance." Same for the bullet employed. Pls forgive my shortened here..."Do not choose a cartridge for when everything goes right. Choose your cartridge for when everything goes wrong." To me, that's called insurance. That insurance gets us closer to meeting the ethics standard we should all aspire to. Use what is required, not just what is comfortable. If it's uncomfortable, learn to manage it. Don't compromise on the cartridge. Your game animal deserves better. Cheers & good hunting everyone. Danny |
|
@ 12:17 am (GMT) |
Mj WentworthRe: 7mm-08 garbage[code]Amen brother. I personally have 6 of my rifles chambered in 7mm-08 Rem - my 1st one being the Browning Xbolt Hell's Canyon Speed, and the others ranging from a budget Ruger American gen 2, up to a Christensen which cost me more than I care to think about this morning. My 2 cents - I had issues with ammo for my Browning - it would not shoot Winchester deer season ammo- i mean 5 boxes and my spotter couldn't once pick up so much as a puff of dust off the burm from anywhere inside 100yds - this is after bore sighting with my green laser visible in the high noon sunshine in July at 100yds, with my Caldwell lead "sled" ( not the older style fixed buttstock holder - the one with the open back which I use bags for) Caldwell Stable Table and all conditions that we've been using to zero our rifles for 40 years. The burm is a 16'L x 12'H bulldozed pile, and my target platform is an 8'x 8' section of pressure treated lumber that was once a part of my back deck prior to the ice storm that mother nature sent us some years back that dropped enough weight from the roof 3 stories above to level that 48'x8 deck clear off the house and down into a pile. So, with some 2x4s as bracing to stand that deck upright, it sits in front of the burm, and I then staple my targets to cardboard and that to the deck. So, bad ammo? After I got frustrated and stood up to shoot from the hip (almost jokingly as I had just said to my ol' man 'shit I could have at least put a few rounds on the paper shooting from the hip or with no scope!" (PS I had at that point tried several different optics, several different bore sighting including the manual bolt out, eye down the barrel adjust my turrets to the orange) Different mounts, and many different shooters) so anyway, i literally put a few rounds from the hip and saw the impact finally! It was a solid 20ft away in the grass... So I decided to try some different ammo. Hornady American Whitetail - 1st 3 round group was sub moa. At least it wasn't the new $1349 Rifle. So, back to the various loads and the fact that I also have a great affinity for my 7mm rem mag, my 7mm Backcountry, my 260rem, my 270win, my 280AI, and that's for all of my shooting - from whitetail here in New England, to Elk & mule deer out west in Montana Wyoming and The Dakotas, and the mag loads for moose, black bear, and elephant. (Just seeing if you were paying attention - no elephant on my kill list. Or any safari types... Mexico trip got some nice ram horn- and a trip down to Kentucky fried up some crispy bacon, flank and all the rest of the razorbacks that hunt. I use the 7mm-08 as a go to, unless it comes down to the point where I am going to be up against the Long range on big game that is more likely to be a shoot to wound - an unethical boundary I don't care to cross. I was thinking about this article - suggesting to shoot for the legs - and I just can't get myself to imagine doing that. Not that I don't think I could, the shot placement is something the corp turned into a second nature with the same likeness as, well, breathing or blinking. But I have been interested in these higher grain factory loads I'm reading about. I've been a 140gr out the box for 7mm-08, and the hand loads 150 with the ELD-X or something similar. But 160 to 180? I'm gonna have to say I'm beyond curious. Especially when I'm currently in the midst of the rut in northern New Hampshire regular rifle season for Whitetail. In fact I'm just going to have to stop this novel and get back to this new to me forum later on. I only just discovered it after stumbling upon an article on the 7mm-08 (a history lesson I did not need to read again for it's all but engrained to the back of my eyelids at this point) but it's going to be fun reading and responding to some of those fellas discussing their beards... Hehehe. Take care partner, happy hunting. MJ[color=orange][/color][size=9][/size] |
|
@ 12:53 am (GMT) |
Mike WentworthRe: 7mm-08 garbagePSI didn't know this was replying in line to the previous responses - and I apologize for the typos- and left out pieces of thoughts-- biggest one was the higger grain pill factory loads and the fact that I'm in the great North Woods where it's a miracle to get a shot further than 50yds - tight mountainside still hunting - not a place to set up a tree stand nor sit up high on a ridge and be able to see anything beyond the exceptionally tall pines, hemlock, oak, and even though there's indeed oak & sugar maples, i.e. hardwood's, it's a series of rolling peaks and valleys, and the fact that really sucks is #1 most of the Private land is posted and the public land was logged heavily over the past 4 to 6 years making it either very rough walking, and/OR a freaking jungle of fresh regrowth just like these old bucks love! They have cover, a zillion escape routes, food, water and despite the rut, it's cold but no snow, ergo crunchy leaves and branches to make it really good for being stealth lol. I'm just playing the wind, tracking, using my grunts and rattles with the rack of last year's 12pt 216lb buck. And he was a small one for this area. No one hunts this area anymore. Seriously - I'm all alone out here. And that is where I need to say adios amigos. Oh and -- hand loads - was saying 150gr was the heaviest pill I went up to. Oh and that buck last year - granted I took him at 67 yds which was far for these parts - but it was with my Ruger American 7mm-08 - 139grain Hornady American Whitetail, double lung shot, he jumped flag was all I saw for a split second as he bounded through the slash - and about 40 yds later he was down. Still approached with my sidearm ready- S&W M&P Shield M2.0 45acp never leave home without it. Everyday carry, with a Glock 26 as my backup, and a. 38 snub as my backup to my backup - the boot- and the Ruger security that's in my pocket is a little bit light for most situations, but it's only in the event I can't draw from my hip, pull from my back on the G26, and gid forbid get myself into a situation where I need to go for the boot - - and if that's all happened - chances are I'm already out drawn, hit, and trying to put down a very large man on angel dust. In which case, I'm better off throwing my 380 at him - JK I'd definitely go with all 7 to the head at that point and have my kabar ready to stab the inner thigh. Whoa too much coffee! Gtg great talking to y'all! |